The Next Matt Schaub?

I spent most of today updating our keeper rankings on the site, taking into account all the free agent and player movement activity. It’s an extremely tedious and time-consuming process, especially when there’s significant movement, but that’s not really my point here today.

One of my points is how the QB position in dire straights. It’s bad out there. There are still roughly 15 good players at the position, but that means more than half the teams in the league have a shaky option – or a terrible one. And forget about young prospects; they don’t really exist. I’m sure the proliferation of spread/shotgun offenses in college have something to do with this, but there’s also an odd dearth in prototypical passers out there lately (which is exactly why everyone should be looking out for John Skelton out of Fordham, since he’s a physically impressive QB whose size and arm strength compare to Joe Flacco’s).

Despite never throwing an NFL pass in a real game, Charger QB Charlie Whitehurst is getting a lot of attention as a Restricted Free Agent this spring

But back to the point: it’s a wasteland out there at the position, and that’s exactly why, all of a sudden, 3rd string backup Charlie Whitehurst (whose father, David Whitehurst, was a QB for the Packers in the 70s and 80s) is suddenly a hot commodity as a restricted free agent.

I’ve heard good things about Whitehurst for a couple of years, but who the heck really knows about him because he’s yet to attempt a pass in a real NFL game (he does have 2 carries and a rushing TD).

But apparently, things have gotten so bad in terms of young prospects, that at least two teams (the Cardinals and the Seahawks) are willing to give up a 3rd round pick just to get him. Both teams have extended offers, and if Whitehurst signs one of them and the Chargers fail to match, this is a guy who could quickly land on the fantasy radar (he should be now, actually, for those in keeper or dynasty leagues).

And you know what? I don’t blame those teams at all. Whitehurst has the tools and pedigree you like to see, and as I’ve said he’s shown promise in SD the last couple of years. In fact, I’m kind of surprised he’s not generating more interest out there. The Rams, Bills, Browns, and Raiders could really use a prospect who seems to actually have a chance to eventually develop into a good player.

And by the way, the fact that the Cardinals are seemingly willing to give up a #3 pick for Whitehurst isn’t exactly a ringing endorsement for one Matt Leinart.

Again, I really have no idea about this kid, but I do think he’s intriguing. Maybe I think that because there’s absolute skank at the position in terms of young prospects, but it is what it is.

If you’re in a dynasty or deep, deep keeper league, I’d take a look at this guy.

Here’s his rookie profile we have on the site from 2006. It’s worth noting that a lot of his issues are correctable problems with proper coaching, and Norv Turner is one of the better QB coaches the league has ever seen.

Full Name: Charlie Whitehurst School: Clemson

Ht: 6-4.5 Wt: 223 40: 4.78 Year: 5S

Bio: Moved into the starting lineup as a redshirt freshman. All-Conference selection two of the past three seasons. Senior passing totals included 66.9%/2,278/11 after a junior campaign of 50.7%/2,067/7/17. Career-best passing yardage numbers of 3,561 came as a sophomore.

Positives: Nice-sized athletic passer with an inconsistent game. Displays a sense of timing, sets up with proper fundamentals and quickly releases the ball. Tough, stands in against the rush and is patient when given time. Throws with an over-the-top delivery and has an NFL arm.

Negatives: Indecisive, not poised under pressure and makes poor decisions. Falls out of throws and tends to direct passes. Forces the action as the pocket collapses around him.

Final Analysis: Possessing the physical skills to play at the next level, Whitehurst has yet to display the consistent decision-making required of an NFL starter. Practice-squad passer best served spending a season or two in Europe.

Category: Fantasy Football, Keeper & Dynasty Blog


5 Responses

  1. Stretch says:


    What’s your take on D.Anderson QB in Arizona. I feel he has walked into the perfect situation. He also has inherit a great receiver corp with Fitz, Breaston, & Doucet that do not have the dropsies. As we all know WRs can make a QB look outstanding.

    M.Leinart wants to be in Hollywood. DA will be the starting QB by mid-season or even sooner. Plus, Coach Whisenhunt do not have any confidence in Leinart.

    K.Warner was around 36yrs old when he beat out M.Leinart for the starting QB job. I believe DA is younger and definitely have a stronger arm than Leinart.

    This QB competition will be won by DA probably in training camp.

  2. […] be a good time to nab him in your dynasty league(s). Perhaps in the right system he could become the next Matt Schaub. [Fantasy […]

  3. JBeau says:

    Just traded to Seahawks. Looks like possibly the next starter after Hassleback. Looks like the Hawks wont be looking towards QB in the draft. I think this means they go OL and then RB or WR in the draft.

  4. John Hansen says:

    Leinart has been named the starter, and he’d have to fall on his face to lose the job, but I do like the Anderson addition. This is from the player movement review we will have up tomorrow, it’s expanded from what’s up there now.

    The Cardinals wanted to add a veteran QB with starting experience to team with and/or challenge Matt Leinart, and Anderson fit the bill pretty well. You could argue that, in a way, this signing may also be a vote of confidence in Leinart, who fell by the wayside as Kurt Warner solidified his Hall-of-Fame credentials the past few years. Upon this signing, Leinart was officially deemed the starter by head coach Ken Whisenhunt, as well. Anderson has been notoriously bad since signing a big deal after his fine 2007 season, and no team two years removed from a Super Bowl should want him as its starting QB. Since the start of the 2008 season, Anderson has completed less than 50% of his passes with a 12/18 TD/INT ratio, and although his arm is as strong as any, his accuracy issues are a major problem. On the other hand, the pickings are quite slim at the QB position, so Anderson made a lot of sense for Arizona and he could conceivably challenge Leinart for playing time at some point. There’s certainly little harm in having him come in to compete, even if he’s a clear #2. It should be noted that the Brown offenses of the past couple years have been historically bad – not just at the QB position, but overall. So Anderson should be helped by moving out to the desert. This is a player who accounted for 32 TDs just two seasons ago and was on the other end of a breakout 2007 season for wideout Braylon Edwards. Accuracy isn’t as important when you’re driving the ball extremely well as he does and throwing the ball to one Larry Fitzgerald, plus the team has two other solid receivers and what looks like a terrific tandem at RB. This is a very good offense for him.

Leave a Reply