- Guru Database: Deep Stats- 5 Years, customizable
- Customized Projections
- Fantasy Football Cheat Sheets, SOS Tool, Points Allowed Tool
- Best Fantasy Football Strategy Articles around
- Tons of News & Inside information
- Trade/Roster Analyzers
- Blogs, Message Boards, Expert Chats, Informative Podcasts, Video Reports, more
- Free Baseball Content

2008 Player Movement Review
Writeups by: Arnold Zappasodi, Staff
Writer
Fantasy Analysis by: John Hansen, Publisher
Published, March 19, 2008
As the NFL’s off-season flies by faster than a Coen Brothers Oscar acceptance speech, it’s already time to get serious about breaking the 2008 season down. Soon, the NFL draft will have come and gone, and the fantasy landscape will have been reseeded and formed for yet another NFL season.
The first step in navigating through the 2008 NFL scene is analyzing this year’s free agent class. There were a few interesting developments, but this year’s movement is, overall, quite lame. Of more importance this year is understanding the fantasy ramifications of the moves, not necessarily the moves themselves and their individual fantasy impacts. For example, no one this summer is going to have trouble containing his or her excitement over the drafting of one Julius Jones, but his addition in Seattle creates, for the first time in a long time, a committee situation in the Pacific Northwest – and likely the drafting of Shaun Alexander’s walking papers. You’re not doing handstands about the LaBrandon Toefield acquisition in Carolina, but you may be if you’re a DeAngelo Williams owner because that signing is a clear indication that Williams has an excellent chance to be “the man” in 2008. And so on and so forth.
With the bulk of the key free agents signed by their new teams, here’s our look at the top moves, broken down by position. Online, we have a ton of info and analysis on non-skill players, including offensive linemen and defensive players.
Quarterbacks
1.
Josh McCown
(QB, signed by
Miami from Oakland)
- McCown left his
backup/spot-starter role with Oakland and signed a two-year .25
million contract with the Dolphins, presumably to compete with young
QB
John Beck for the starting
job. In 2007, McCown started nine games for the Raiders. He was very
ordinary, throwing for 1,151 yards with 10 TDs and 11 INTs. It looks
like he was picked up off the free-agent market by Miami for his
respectable experience, as he’s started 31 games in his six-year
career. Plus, he’s going to be just 29 next season, and Miami is
clearly building for the future. Look for the Dolphins to draft or
possibly trade for another viable starting QB this spring, making
the uninspiring McCown no sure-fire bet to start out of the gates in
2008.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: I’ve been intrigued
by McCown’s tools – a strong arm, good mobility, and solid overall
athleticism – for a little while now, but I’m still waiting for his
abilities to translate into production, and, of course, into wins.
His career 35-40 TD-INT ratio in his six years pretty much tells you
all you need to know about his career thus far. Perhaps being in a
complex system in Detroit, and in a less-than-ideal place in Oakland
the last two years, has sabotaged his chances. In Miami, McCown will
likely be asked to operate in a relatively simple system, which
should help, since McCown doesn’t exactly have a reputation for
being, shall I say, cerebral. Unfortunately, his supporting cast at
receiver is horrible, his line is mediocre, and his running game is
in a shaky state with
Ronnie Brown coming off ACL
surgery (it’s going well thing spring, at least) and
Ricky Williams
never a sure thing. And while he should have a good chance to beat
out the youngster Beck (or a potential high 2008 draft pick), McCown
will be in a situation in which he has to play well and the team has
to be in the race to keep his starting gig. In other words, this is
not the stuff of fantasy legend.
2. Trent
Green
(QB, signed by
St. Louis from Miami)
- After being cut loose by the
Dolphins and getting clearance from his doctor to return to the
field after another ugly concussion in 2007, the 37-year-old veteran
Green signed a three-year .9 million contract with the Rams to back
up oft-injured QB
Marc Bulger. Green’s first
and only season with Miami was a debacle. He played in just five
games, throwing for 987 yards with 5 TDs and 7 INTs before getting
knocked cold laying a low block.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: Green is, of course,
very familiar and comfortable with new Ram OC
Al Saunders
from his previous stay in St. Louis and his days with Kansas City,
plus his old buddy
Terry Shea
is there coaching the offense. So it’s a great fit for the Rams and
also for Green if he’s ever called upon to start. But Green’s like a
birthday candle at this point. One blow and he’s out. And playing
behind that shoddy (but at least recently improved) Ram O-line is a
scary proposition. I still can’t believe he’d take this gig given
his issues, and while the move on paper makes sense it’s hard for me
to say that this move bolsters the value and reduces the downside of
their key skill players.
3.
Brian Griese
(QB, signed by
Tampa Bay from Chicago)
- The Bears decided to deal
Griese to the Bucs, since Chicago’s set to roll with QB
Rex Grossman and QB
Kyle Orton in 2008. Last
season, the 33-year-old Griese started six games, throwing for 1,803
yards, with 10 TDs and 12 INTs on the year. This will be his second
go-round with Tampa Bay, but he’ll just be a backup, and it would
take massive injuries for him to see action. The trade just shows
that head coach
Jon Gruden will hire anyone
because Griese is the definition of a week-to-week guy.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: Griese at least knows
the system well, and he did play at a surprisingly high level for
most of his stint as the starter last year, even stepping into his
throws and taking some hits, two things he hasn’t always done.
Griese will battle the promising
Luke McCown for the backup
job, so Bruce
Gradkowski’s roster spot will
be in jeopardy. It would appear now that
Chris Simms will be the odd
man out. Having Griese on the roster will at least give the team a
reliable veteran should
Jeff Garcia
get hurt, so that does help the values of their other skill players
a tiny bit.
4.
Mark Brunell
(QB, signed by
New Orleans from Washington)
– The free-agent 37-year-old
Brunell wasn’t wanted back by the Redskins, so he elected to ink a
two-year contract with the Saints, financial terms undisclosed.
He’ll most likely be QB
Drew Brees’
primary backup in 2008. Last season in his fifteenth year as a pro,
Brunell didn’t even sniff the field, as he lost his #2 job to QB
Todd Collins. Maybe head
coach Sean Payton
likes the idea of the veteran lefty mentoring and teaching young
southpaw QB
Tyler Palko because
Brunell’s not much of a playmaker any more.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: I’d say Brunell is a
significantly better insurance policy than last year’s backup,
Jamie Martin.
That’s not exactly a ringing endorsement, but Brunell is clearly an
experienced veteran who should be able to maintain the values of
their key skill players for at least a short period of time should
Brees miss some time. Brunell isn’t a great long-term answer, but he
should be a solid game manager and fit for this offense, one that
focuses more on shorter passes than it does longer ones. It’s worth
noting that the Saint line has done a good job protecting the
quarterback the last two years, so Brunell should have success if
forced to start.
5.
Cleo Lemon
(QB, signed by Jacksonville from Miami)
-
Lemon signed a three-year .1 million contract with the Jags to be
the backup to QB
David Garrard, as
established second-string QB
Quinn Gray was expected at
the time of the signing to test the free-agent market and agree to
terms with a new team this off-season. In 2007, Lemon started seven
games for the Dolphins. He passed for 1,773 yards with 6 TDs, 6
INTs, and 4 rushing TDs and posted a lousy QB rating of 71. He’ll be
29 next season, and his mobility and ability to be a game-manager
certainly appealed to head coach
Jack Del Rio.
The Jags better hope they don’t need him for a long stretch in 2008,
though. After all, he showed an erratic streak with his accuracy,
made some horrible decisions, and took a ton of unnecessary sacks
last season in the most extensive action of his four-year career.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: Not much to add here,
only that the team likely viewed him as a safer and better
alternative to
Quinn Gray, who did a
rock-solid job subbing for an injured
David Garrard
last year. Either that, or they figured Gray, who will now look for
a better opportunity, would cost more than Lemon. To me this signing
signifies a Jaguar team that is ready to make a serious run to the
playoffs, and one that would rather put their passing game in the
hands of a savvier veteran in Lemon compared to Gray, should Garrard
get hurt. I’m not sure Lemon is better than Gray, but he’s
definitely more experienced, and there are a lot of elements to his
game – good mobility, a strong arm, and an ability to make things
happen – that are comparable to Garrard.
6.
J.T. O'Sullivan
(QB, signed by
San Francisco from Detroit)
– O’Sullivan, a favorite of
Niner OC Mike
Martz,
signed a one-year 5,000
contract with the 49ers to be the #3 QB and emergency guy behind QB
Alex Smith and QB
Shaun Hill. He’ll be 29
next season, and he has thrown for just 148 yards, with 1 TD and 2
INTs in his six-year career.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: It’s obvious that his
knowledge of Martz’s detailed offensive system was a major factor in
this move because O’Sullivan hasn’t done much in the past to instill
confidence. It’s also important to note that starter
Alex Smith is coming off
shoulder surgery and there’s a chance
Shaun Hill
will have the inside track on the starting job in the summer if
Smith’s not 100%. Just in case Hill flops, O’Sullivan at least knows
the system.
7.
David Carr
(QB, signed by
New York Giants from Carolina)
– Cut by the Panthers after
playing like a stiff in his first year there, Carr signed a one-year
million deal with the Giants to back up QB
Eli Manning. In 2007, the
28-year-old Carr started four games and played in six total
contests, throwing for 635 yards with 3 TDs and 5 INTs for an
embarrassing QB rating of 58.3. Carr’s reportedly very close with
Giant QB coach
Chris Palmer from their days
together in Houston, which sort of explains this bad move for New
York. And it’s clear that Carr’s starting experience (four full
seasons with 16 starts under his belt) played a role in this signing
because he’s a complete mess and he cannot be relied on.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: I understand the
connection to Palmer, but why, why, why? Luckily for the Giants, all
Mannings are durable, so perhaps that was a factor with this
signing. After all, I wouldn’t mind it too much if my second car was
a Kia – as long as my primary vehicle was a Porsche. Surely, if
Eli Manning had some
durability issues the team would be less inclined to bring Carr into
the fold. Regardless, it’s not exactly great news for the Giant
skill players. Make no mistake: If Manning goes down, all the Giant
skill players will be killed, much like
Steve Smith
was killed last year. If you watched Carr play a lot last year, and
especially if you watched him on film as those I know did, you’d
come to one single conclusion: Carr can’t play NFL football.
Running Backs
1. Michael
Turner
(RB, signed by
Atlanta from San Diego) –
The biggest free-agent runner on
the market signed a six-year .5 million contract with the Falcons
after backing up L.T. in San Diego for his entire four-year career.
While he was a Charger, Turner “The Burner” rushed for 1,257 yards
and 6 TDs, averaging a whopping 5.5 yards/carry and making some
explosive plays in his situational role. At 26 years old, the 5’10”,
237-pound Turner will play the role of the power back in Atlanta’s
backfield alongside speedster and finesse RB
Jerious Norwood. RB
Warrick Dunn has been
released, so he won’t play into the equation for new head coach
Mike Smith, who wants to
emphasize pounding the rock with a duo of versatile backs like
Jacksonville’s two-headed monster of Taylor and Jones-Drew (Smith
coached those two in Jacksonville). More than likely, Turner will be
the thunder and Norwood will be the lightning. Still, we’re going to
see more of Turner than ever before. We’ll see how he responds to
200+ carries.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: While
it would have been nice to see
Turner go to more promising situation such as the one in Houston, he
will clearly have some fantasy value in Atlanta going forward. New
head coach
Mike Smith and offensive
coordinator Mike
Mularkey have similar mindsets
when it comes to offense, and it centers on pounding the ball
between the tackles with a bigger back, and Turner fits the bill
well. Obviously, that’s why they opened up the franchise’s wallet to
retain his services. He’ll give them something to hang their hat on
offensively, an identity. In addition, having a legit lead back will
make it easier for the team to transition to a young franchise
quarterback, likely in 2009. The team will certainly look to take
advantage of
Jerious Norwood’s big-play
ability, but Turner’s a safe bet to get 18-20 carries each week.
Both will give the offense a big-play flare. The offensive line is
very much a work in progress and will do Turner no favors. The
situation at quarterback isn’t incredibly promising, either, but at
least
Chris Redman
showed in ’07 that he could throw the ball well, get the ball to his
receivers, and most important, run an offense and manage a game. He
may be serviceable this year, which would help Turner a ton. But
ultimately, since this isn’t the greatest situation, since he’s
still unproven as a lead guy, and since Norwood will command at
least a few carries each week, Turner can’t be considered a terrific
#2 fantasy back at this early stage.
2. Julius
Jones
(RB, signed by
Seattle from Dallas)
- Jones used free agency to get
out of Dallas, where he was grossly underused in 2007. He signed a
reported four-year million contract with the Seahawks, seemingly to
compete for the bell-cow role in 2008. In 2007, the 26-year-old
Jones rushed for 588 yards and 2 TDs, adding 23/203 as a receiver.
In his four-year stay with the Cowboys, he averaged 3.9 yards/carry
and scored 18 TDs, but he managed just one 1,000-yard campaign.
Seattle has made it a point this off-season to bolster their running
game after it let them down last season. Ultimately, Jones has the
speed and hands to be a difference-maker in Seattle’s offense,
especially if the team parts ways with RB
Shaun Alexander. But his
5’10”, 208-pound frame could prevent him from thriving between the
tackles.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: Jones has some
issues, for sure, but I have to say I like this move for him.
Seattle’s offense is pass-oriented, which is just fine for Jones
actually, yet they clearly appreciated how they needed to upgrade
their running game. I heard last year from a very good source that
head coach Mike
Holmgren was incredibly
perturbed with the production and, more important, the play of
Alexander last year, and you can’t blame him. That said, I would
expect Alexander to be gone, and I’m sure the Seahawks feel good
about how Jones fits into their system and improves their running
game. Their line isn’t nearly what it once was, but it’s decent
enough (adding veteran G
Mike Wahl
helps), and if they continue to be a
pass-oriented team, there should be opportunities on screens, draws,
delays, etc. for Jones to take better advantage of his speed. If
they chose to get more physical on the ground, then they can turn to
veteran
T.J. Duckett, who was solid
last year in limited time. One complication is the presence of
Maurice Morris, who is a
smaller and speedier back who has shown some game and versatility.
It’s hard to say with the utmost confidence that Jones should make
Morris irrelevant, but as long as things are going well, Jones
should be the presumptive “starter” based solely on his contract in
what could wind up as something of a committee, if not a serious
one. But another problem is the loss of wideout
D.J. Hackett. If
Deion Branch
isn’t healthy enough to play at a high level early in the season,
which is likely, then Seattle’s receiving is quite weak. That’s a
problem for Jones, for sure. At this early stage, while I think
there is still some upside as a fantasy backup, I’m certainly not
going to invest heavily in him and assume he’ll be a fantasy
savior.
3. Chris
Brown
(RB, signed by Houston from Tennessee)
- The oft-injured free-agent Brown wore out his
welcome in Tennessee with inconsistent play over the past five
seasons. As a result, the Texans jumped on him, signing Brown to a
two-year .6 million deal, presumably to share carries with RB
Ahman Green in 2008. Head
coach Gary Kubiak
reportedly felt that Brown’s big-play potential and one-cut-and-go
style were too good a fit for Houston’s offensive scheme to pass up.
Brown’s signing probably signals the end of the line for RB
Ron Dayne in Houston. In
2007, Brown rushed for 462 yards and 5 TDs, averaging an impressive
4.5 yards/carry and posting 19/128 as a pass-catcher. Soon to be 27
years old with just over 700 career touches, Brown has some good
days ahead of him, for sure, if he doesn’t dog it. But he’s awfully
soft, and it’s only a matter of time before he’s crying about some
malady.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: My initial impression
upon hearing of this signing was that a RBBC situation got worse,
but Brown does make some sense for the Texans. They plan on keeping
Ahman Green around for now,
so Brown gives them a veteran fall-back option. And in Brown, they
get a veteran insurance policy who also has some upside, unlike the
workmanlike
Ron Dayne. Brown has always
had an intriguing skill set, and he’s a good fit for their system,
at least in theory. If he takes to the system well (he ran in a
similar system to Denver’s patented zone blocking scheme in
college), he could certainly rack up significant yardage if carrying
the load here. Keep in mind this offense could be surprisingly
lethal in 2008, given the attractive talent they have on the roster.
Of course, Brown’s a major injury risk, Green is in the mix,
youngster Darious
Walker could
still compete for playing time as at least a 3rd down
back, and the Texans will likely draft a back fairly early in this
year’s draft. So while Brown will warrant a later pick as a 4th
or 5th back due to his upside, the main thing he does
here for now is further complicate this team’s backfield situation.
4. DeShaun
Foster
(RB, signed by
San Francisco from Carolina)
– After the Panthers gave up on
their bell-cow and released him, Foster on Monday (3/3) officially
signed what was reported to be a two-year .8 million contract with
the 49ers. In 2007, Foster started all 16 games for the first time
in his six-year career, yet his numbers were simply okay. He rushed
for 876 yards and 3 TDs, averaged a career-low 3.5 yards/carry, and
posted 25/182/1 as a receiver.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: At 28 years old,
Foster is fresh, young, and sizeable enough to be an effective
change-of-pace back for San Francisco. There’s no question he has
the experience and know-how to step in as a spot-starter should
Frank Gore continue to get
banged up. The only issue with Foster is that he lacks explosiveness
and dynamism and struggles with fumbling. He’ll compete with
recently re-signed RB
Michael Robinson for the
backup job to RB
Frank Gore,
but it’s very safe to assume Foster will be the clear backup. And
now that he’s officially a backup, let me officially say that Foster
is a damn good one. The good news, too, is that we can all rest easy
knowing we (finally) have a clear handle on the handcuff for Gore.
Foster is a decent receiver with some power; he’d be solid if Gore
went down. He'll also play a fair amount as a runner and a
(especially) as a receiver alongside Gore. While that may seem like
a negative, working Foster into the flow of the offense should help
keep Gore fresh and healthy.
5. Warrick
Dunn
(RB, signed by
Tampa Bay from Atlanta)
- Shown the door by the Falcons
after six seasons, the 33-year-old Dunn signed a two-year million
contract to return to the Bucs and compete for carries with RB
Michael Bennett behind
starting RB
Earnest Graham. Dunn’s
production declined dramatically in 2007. He rushed for 720 yards
and 4 TDs, averaging a measly 3.2 yards/carry. He also posted 37/238
as a receiver. Speaking of catching passes, Dunn’s agent reportedly
was told by head coach
Jon Gruden
that he will play a big role as a pass-catcher in the offense in
2008. As far as carries go, though, Dunn will likely play second
fiddle to Graham, unless an injury opens the door. At the very
least, he brings durability, depth, and experience to the Buc ground
game, even if he’s slated to be just a complementary back.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: To me this signing is
a severe blow to Graham’s value. Those I know who studied Dunn on
tape last year felt he was still playing at a pretty high level, so
it’s not like there’s been a noticeable drop-off in Dunn’s game
(amazingly). He can still run effectively in between the tackles and
bust off the occasional long run. Dunn’s been underused in the
passing game for years, but he’s not a bad receiver, either, so he’s
capable of chipping away at Graham’s production in the passing game.
With Dunn now in the fold, I would be hesitant to draft Graham as my
#2 back. Graham was very solid last year, but we have to recognize
how he was a deep backup for several NFL seasons, so he’s not
exactly bursting with talent. Also, I should note that this move is
a clear sign that
Carnell Williams
won’t be ready to play to start the season.
6. LaBrandon
Toefield
(RB, signed by
Carolina from Jacksonville)
- The free-agent former-Jag
Toefield inked a one-year 0,000 deal to play for the Panthers. Last
season, the 27-year-old Toefield rarely saw the field behind RB
Fred Taylor and RB
Maurice Jones-Drew, rushing
for just 27 yards and 1 TD. In his five-year stay with Jacksonville,
Toefield averaged 3.5 yards/carry and notched 9 TDs, but he was
never anything more than a role player. At 5’11”, 235, chances are
he’ll be a bruising complement to starting RB
DeAngelo Williams in 2008,
seeing action in short-yardage and goal-line situations and giving
the team a powerful change of pace to the speedy Williams.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: Hey,
this is great news for Williams. I’d be concerned about Williams’
fantasy prospects this year if the team drafted a back very high, or
if they brought in a higher level free agent. Toefield is the bigger
back they need, and he can give them a change of pace and possibly
solid work at the goal. But if he’s a “change of-pace” that means
that Williams is the man, and that (finally) has to be the
expectation now. It looks like we’re going to finally see what
Williams can do as the lead back in Carolina. If healthy, he should
be a very good yardage producer on a team that should have an
effective passing game in 2008. As for Toefield, he's definitely
worth a late pick at this point (unless the team drafts a back
high), especially if you draft Williams. Williams does have some
durability issues, so if unless the team brings in another quality
back via the draft, Toefield could very well get a few starts (at
least) for the Panthers.
7. Jesse
Chatman
(RB,
signed by NY Jets from Miami) -
Chatman left the Dolphins via free agency and signed a one-year
contract with the Jets, financial terms undisclosed. Last year, the
28-year-old Chatman had his best year in the NFL, rushing for 515
yards and 1 TD and posting 27/161 as a pass-catcher. The Jets needed
a big, bulky runner to complement the smaller speedster
Leon Washington. Chatman,
who is 5-8 223 and a load to bring down when he gets going, fits the
bill well. Yet, his track record isn’t pretty and he’s had issues
keeping his weight down, so this was a risky move by New York.
Hansen’s Fantasy Analysis:
I’ll say this for Chatman: his former coaches are loyal to him. He
got a second chance last year under former coach
Cam Cameron
in Miami, and now another former offensive coach in San Diego, Jet
offensive coordinator
Brian Schottenheimer,
has
given him an endorsement. This is a
pretty good addition for the Jets because, when you consider their
unwillingness to utilize Washington a ton out of the backfield, they
really had no one else. Chatman gives them a somewhat solid and
reliable backup option who has some physicality and versatility as a
pass catcher. I’m not sure if he’s a must-have if you draft Jones,
but he’d certainly be worth picking up for depth if Jones went down.
Again, until further notice, we have to assume the Jets have little
interest in taking advantage of Washington’s intriguing talent,
which is pretty mind-boggling.
8. T.J.
Duckett
(RB, signed by
Seattle from Detroit)
- Seattle signed this 254-pound,
27-year-old free agent to be a complementary back and a goal-line
threat after their duo of RB
Shaun Alexander and RB
Maurice Morris struggled
immensely in short-yardage situations last season. Duckett, who left
the Lions, inked a five-year deal, financial terms undisclosed. In
2007, he averaged a career-high 5.2 yards/carry and rushed for 335
yards and 3 TDs. With 36 career TDs to his credit, it seems likely
he’ll carve a niche in the red zone and give Seattle a strong
between-the-tackles force.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: Duckett has been
around for a little while, but he’s still only 27 years old, so he’s
not even reached his critical prime. The fact that he’s bounced
around is more of an issue, since this will be his fourth team in as
many seasons. But Duckett was actually as good as ever for the Lions
in 2007, albeit it in a limited role, averaging 5.2 yards per carry,
so this looks like a worthwhile option for Seattle in 2008 while
they try to figure out their unsettled running back situation. With
the team not expected to keep veteran
Shaun Alexander
for another year, Duckett will give them some physicality to their
running game and could conceivably take over the goal line duties.
That’s a key point for Duckett because, with Jones in the fold and
Morris still around, the only change Duckett has to make a fantasy
splash, barring an injury, is to be the team’s primary goal line
back.
9. Mewelde
Moore
(RB, signed by
Pittsburgh from Minnesota)
- Moore, an underused
25-year-old free agent, left the RB logjam in Minnesota and signed a
three-year .95 million contract with Pittsburgh. He rarely saw the
field in 2007 behind RB
Adrian Peterson and RB
Chester Taylor, so he
rushed for only 113 yards and posted just 6/48 as a pass-catcher.
Yet, in his four-year career, the speedy, versatile Moore has
averaged nearly 5 yards/carry and almost 10 yards/catch, showing
signs of major explosiveness on the edges. With that said, he’ll
probably contribute for the Steelers in 2008 as a change-of-pace to
bell-cow RB
Willie Parker, a
situational receiver, and a special teamer. His upside, quickness,
and elusiveness were coveted by head coach
Mike Tomlin,
who knows Moore well from 2006 when he was the DC with the Vikings.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: This is an
interesting signing to me because I know what Moore can do, having
followed him closely over the years. While it's highly questionable
Moore can hold up if given a significant number of touches over an
extended period of time, he has a lot to offer in a complementary
role. As mentioned above, Moore has attractive quickness and
elusiveness, as well as some very nifty natural run instincts and
ability, plus he's a very capable and productive receiver. I have to
imagine that his addition won't help
Willie Parker's numbers, at
least Parker's receiving numbers (not that he does much in the
passing game to begin with). However, until we actually see Moore in
a Steeler uniform this summer and get some concrete information on
his role, it's hard to expect him to get a ton of touches each week.
After all, the team does still have
Najeh Davenport,
who did a nice job last year behind Parker and who can catch the
ball as well. Moore, I should mention, can help the Steelers in the
return game, and that will likely be his primary role.
10. Maurice
Hicks (RB,
signed by Minnesota from San Francisco)
- The
29-year-old free-agent Hicks bid farewell to the Niners and signed a
three-year contract with Minnesota, financial terms undisclosed. In
his four-year stay with San Francisco, Hicks rushed for just 869
yards and 6 TDs as a reserve. But he added 55/424/1 as a receiver,
played a major role as a kick returner, and averaged a nice 4.2
yards/carry. Minnesota obviously has a loaded backfield with RB
Adrian Peterson and RB
Chester Taylor, but the
coaching staff has informed Hicks that he’ll see action on
third-down and be expected to contribute on special teams. Losing RB
Mewelde Moore to the
Steelers forced this depth move for the Vikings.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: As mentioned above,
Hicks will supposedly see time this year as a 3rd-down
back, although I’ll believe that when I see it because the team
already has
Chester Taylor and wasn’t
inclined to use the very capable
Mewelde Moore
much in that role last year. That’s not to say this was a bad
acquisition because it was actually quite a good one. In Hicks, they
get a nice player for a #3 back, plus he can help them substantially
in kick returns. If the top two guys go down, he can even start in a
pinch.
Wide Receivers
1. Bernard
Berrian
(WR, signed by
Minnesota from Chicago) –
Berrian scoffed at the Bears’
skimpy offer sheet and took full advantage of his free-agent status
by signing a six-year million contract with the Vikings. He’s coming
off a career year in 2007 in which he posted 71/951/5. Minnesota
apparently told him what he wanted to hear – namely that he’ll be
the top receiver for them in front of WR
Sidney Rice and WR
Bobby Wade. After four
years with shaky QB play in Chicago, however, the 27-year-old
Berrian could have to deal with more issues in Minnesota given QB
Tarvaris Jackson’s
atrocious mechanics. But his speed and big-play potential should be
maximized on the fast turf inside the dome at Viking home games at
least. Many teams sighed when Berrian was taken off the market, as
he was highly coveted around the NFL for his upside. We’ll see how
he copes with the pressure of being a go-to guy.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: I love Berrian, and I
credit the Vikes for bringing him in, but it’s questionable as to
whether or not this move goes down as a wise one. The move on paper
does make a lot of sense at least. Although he’s not a legit #1,
something the team ideally needs, he’s a major upgrade at the
position. Most important, he’s an explosive threat who will severely
challenge defenses vertically, which is a very important factor for
the Vikings, who run the rock a ton and who have an elite talent in
Adrian Peterson, who needs
some pressure taken off him. But ultimately, Berrian’s success will
hinge on the development of quarterback
Tarvaris Jackson, and I’m
not very encouraged by the young QB. Berrian isn’t exactly a player
who will make a QB better; he’s capable of doing very well, but also
capable of stumbling if his quarterback is less than stellar.
Jackson has a lot to learn about reading defenses, scanning the
field efficiently, and making quick and proper decisions. He also
has some physical limitations (lack of height) and some major
mechanical issues to work out. Jackson at least throws a nice deep
ball, and the Vikings should be solid in pass protection, two
factors that will help Berrian. Berrian is expected to start
alongside
Sidney Rice, which is an
intriguing pairing but one that probably won’t be extremely
productive in 2008 unless Jackson miraculously transforms into an
above-average NFL quarterback. As for the Bears, they are perilously
thin now at receiver. At this point, they may have to count on the
talented but injury-prone
Mark Bradley. As it stands
now, even with veteran
Marty Booker brought into the fold, the player to watch is
Devin Hester.
The Bears are a lot higher on him as a receiver as some think, and
he showed dramatic improvement as a route-runner later in the
season.
2.
Donte Stallworth
(WR, signed by
Cleveland from New England) -
After the Pats decided not to
pay him a massive bonus, Stallworth became a free agent and signed a
seven-year million contract with the Browns to complement WR
Braylon Edwards and TE
Kellen Winslow. In his stay
with New England in 2007, Stallworth was underused, so he managed
just 46/697/3 in nine starts. He has bounced from New Orleans to
Philly to New England these past three years, but he’s found a home
in Cleveland and he’ll be very involved in the vertical passing
game. The six-year vet is only 27 years old and he’ll bring
significant speed and playmaking ability to an already dynamic
offense. Stallworth will likely push WR
Joe Jurevicius to the #3 WR
spot and start opposite Edwards as the #2 guy. QB
Derek Anderson must be one
giddy guy right now with all those weapons.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: This is a great
pickup for the Browns. In Stallworth they have finally added some
top-end speed and quickness to their receiving corps and a #2 who
can actually help their offense. Stallworth can not only help the
Browns, but he can also put them over the top. Perfectly cast
alongside a sizable #1 and an elite TE, Stallworth should have
plenty of opportunities to make plays after the catch and haul in
some bombs from the strong-armed Anderson. As mentioned above, this
move will push veteran Jurevicius to the #3 role, and he can be one
of the better receivers in the league in that spot. As amazing as it
sounds, with their very good line, their efficient running game,
quarterback play, and now receiving corps – not to mention the
excellent coaching and scheming – the Browns are as complete an
offense as you’ll find in the league. I know sometimes we see these
situations that look so good on paper yet they wind up being too
good to be true. But while Stallworth himself may be hit-or-miss
still, what the Browns have done on offense with this addition as
well as re-signing Anderson and
Jamal Lewis,
makes too much sense not to work out in the end.
3. Javon
Walker
(WR, signed by
Oakland from Denver)
– Cut by the Broncos after an
injury-riddled 2007 campaign, the 29-year-old Walker caught on with
the Raiders by inking a massive six-year million deal. His knee was
problematic for much of last season, so he posted just 26/287/0 in
five starts and gave up his go-to status to WR
Brandon Marshall. Since the
Raiders lost WR
Jerry Porter in free
agency, Walker was obviously viewed as a nice replacement with
big-play potential. If his shaky knee doesn’t continue to hamper
him, Walker will surely assume the top role alongside WR
Ronald Curry in 2008 and
give QB
JaMarcus Russell a
deep-threat and a sure-handed, proven target. With 30 career TDs to
his credit, the 6’3”, 215-pound Walker instantly improves Oakland’s
horrendous red zone offense. Still, his health is a complete
question mark, as is the development of Russell.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: I know the Raiders
desperately needed some playmakers at receiver for their young
quarterback, but this move looks like yet another shaky one for
Oakland. It’s one thing for a team close to competing for a
championship to take a calculated risk on Walker because, if somehow
healthy, he could push a good team over the top. That’s why it made
sense for teams like Tampa, Philly, Dallas, and Carolina to show
interest. But the Raiders won’t be challenging for a Super Bowl
berth anytime soon, so unless Walker’s knee holds up for 2-3 years,
they’re bound to be disappointed in this deal. For 2008, even if
Walker’s knee – one that has been problematic for three years and
required two different surgeries in ’07 – cooperates, he’ll still be
working with a QB in Russell who doesn’t seem to be even close to
being considered an effective and productive starter and passer in
the NFL. Unless things are extremely positive this summer with this
situation, I’ll likely pass on Walker because, based on name
recognition and his place atop the depth chart, he’ll probably be
drafted a little earlier than I would normally want to take my #3
fantasy receiver. The addition of
Drew Carter
certainly doesn’t help and adds to a situation that could be
committee-like.
4.
D.J. Hackett
(WR, signed by
Carolina from Seattle)
– The oft-injured free-agent
Hackett thought long and hard about returning to Seattle, but in the
end he chose to sign a reported two-year .5 million deal to play for
the Panthers. In 2007, the 26-year-old Hackett played in just six
games due to a lingering high ankle sprain. When active, he was
lethal both as a field-stretcher and a red zone threat. He posted
32/384/3 and notched a pair of 100-yard performances. Look for him
to slide into the #2 wideout spot in 2008 alongside WR
Steve Smith and ahead of WR
Muhsin Muhammad and WR
Dwayne Jarrett if he can
simply stay healthy. His 6’2”, 208-pound frame and deceptive deep
speed should really help Carolina add some verticality to their
hurting passing game.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: This is great news
for the Panther offense, but not necessarily for Hackett’s
production. He’ll obviously play second-fiddle to Smith, not to
mention Muhammad, who can be a physical receiver for the Panthers.
Durability is also a major concern for Hackett, so he doesn’t look
like a viable fantasy starter right now. The good news is that QB
Jake Delhomme should now be
considered a high-end backup, a top-15 guy, and that Smith should
have some needed pressure taken off of him. I also like the move for
RB
DeAngelo Williams,
since Hackett is a versatile receiver who will command attention,
especially downfield, which will open things up further for the
promising Williams.
5. Jerry
Porter
(WR, signed by
Jacksonville from Oakland)
– Porter said adios to the
Raiders, took full advantage of his free-agent status, and signed a
juicy six-year million contract with the Jags. His addition is a
welcome one, as the Jags have been notoriously thin at wideout (at
least talent-wise) for quite some time, and Porter is a relatively
proven commodity. In 2007, Porter played a full slate of games,
posted 44/705/6, and emerged as the Raiders’ go-to receiver. He’ll
be 30 next season, so he’s far from a spring chicken. Moreover, he
no longer possesses great speed to stretch the field, and injuries
have plagued him in the past. Yet, his 6’2”, 220-pound frame, his
eight years of NFL experience, and his crisp route-running should
help him seriously contribute as a possession guy and make a
difference in the red zone in Jacksonville’s basic passing game.
With WR
Ernest Wilford bolting via
free agency, the table is set for Porter to start immediately and
potentially land the #1 WR job ahead of WR
Reggie Williams in 2008.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: The Jaguar receiving
corps got better, but I’m not so sure tough guy
Jack Del Rio
and the rest of the organization will be thrilled down the road with
Porter, whose track record as a team player isn’t all that great.
But the team claims it’s more than fine with his attitude, and a
fresh start can only help the veteran. Porter’s not a true burner,
but he can run, unlike most of their other receivers. In fact,
compared to the guys they have trotted out on the field the last few
years, Porter’s a serious playmaker. He’ll likely settle in as their
#1, with
Reggie Williams likely to
secure the #2 spot, with
Dennis Northcutt moving
inside to the slot, which is a place he’s best-suited for. Throw in
a decent TE in
Marcedes Lewis, and that’s
a lot of mouths to feed on a team that still wants to run the rock
and one that does so with an excellent two-headed monster. Clearly,
the Jags will look to open up their offense more now, but while
David Garrard
did a fantastic job last year, I still firmly believe he has
limitations as a passer and is better off being more of a
game-manager, as opposed to the captain of a wide-open offense.
Williams did score 10 TDs last year, in case you forgot, and he
developed a good chemistry with Garrard. So ultimately, I can’t
expect Porter, who has yet to prove he truly commands the ball on a
consistent basis, to be anything more than a viable depth/fill-in
guy for fantasy. Garrard, though, should be considered a very
attractive backup, one capable of putting up starter’s numbers due
to his running and passing.
6. Bryant
Johnson
(WR, signed by San Francisco from Arizona)
– The
27-year-old Johnson took advantage of his free-agent status and left
Arizona after five seasons there. He inked a one-year contract with
San Francisco, financial terms unknown. In 2007, Johnson posted
46/528/2 as Arizona’s third wideout, starting eight games and
averaging 11.5 yards/catch. He’s been a highly productive and eerily
consistent role player in his NFL career, so you can bet that
pass-happy OC Mike
Martz will find a way to keep
him involved in 2008. Considering he has more vertical speed and
big-play potential than aging wideouts
Darrell Jackson (since
released) and
Isaac Bruce,
and taking into account the
fact that he has more explosive upside than WR
Arnaz Battle, Johnson
appears poised to win the #2 WR job for the Niners next season. At
the very least, his 6’3”, 213-pound frame will help him stay active
as a possession pass-catcher.
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: Johnson’s a decent
player, but he’s miscast here as an integral part of
Mike Martz’s
offense. Johnson would have been a solid pickup for a team like the
Bills, who have a speedy #1 receiver, but I’m not sure the 49ers
will get a lot of production out of Johnson this year. For one, he’s
not exactly a good fit for Martz’s system, one that typically
features smaller receivers who have excellent quickness. Johnson is
a bigger receiver with only decent speed, and it remains to be seen
if he can excel over the course of a full season as a clear starter.
And, or course, it also remains to be seen if quarterback
Alex Smith can consistently
get him the ball. I would have endorsed Johnson as a nice #4 wideout
in a perfect situation, but this is far from that. One player to
check out this summer is youngster
Jason Hill.
Hill has very good speed and is viewed as a good fit for this
offense. Unfortunately, given the addition of Johnson, Hill’s
potential this year is limited.
7. Isaac
Bruce
(WR, signed by
San Francisco from St. Louis)
– He was released by the Rams
after 14 seasons, but Bruce caught on elsewhere quickly by signing a
two-year million contract with the 49ers. Last year, the 35-year-old
veteran posted 55/733/4 in 12 starts and his productivity declined.
He’s no longer completely durable, and he’s lost the ability to gain
huge separation like he used to. But reuniting with old friend OC
Mike Martz
in San Fran and playing in a
pass-happy scheme could help Bruce experience a slight resurgence if
he stays healthy and sees the field a lot. With nearly 1,000 career
receptions and 84 career TDs,
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: I can’t get excited
about a 35-year-old in his 16th year in this situation,
even though Bruce maintained a high level of play in 2007. He’s back
with Mike Martz,
which is nice and all, but there’s no
Kurt Warner or
Marc Bulger here; it’s
Alex Smith, who hasn’t
shown he can play in the NFL, not to mention in Martz’s demanding
system. Smith’s arm strength is a problem, but it’s not as big an
issue in this system because they throw more short and intermediate
passes than deep ones. The bigger question is can he get a handle on
this timing-based offense very quickly? Those who have studied him
on tape tell me he doesn’t process information quickly enough, which
is surprising because he’s supposed to be a cerebral guy. Unless
Smith’s career takes a dramatic turn under Martz – who can
definitely make him, but also break him – I just can’t find anything
compelling to feel good about here. I will say that I can envision
Bruce handling a key role on the inside in Martz’ offense, and as
we’ve seen recently with guys like Mike Furrey and Shaun McDonald, a
capable receiver who knows the system such as those two and of
course Bruce, can catch a ton of balls in this system. Also
interesting now is the good chance that
Drew Bennett
will start for St. Louis. This was the expectation when they signed
Bennett last year, but he didn’t have a very good showing, so we’ll
have to see if the Rams make a play for another receiver in free
agency or the draft. If not, then Bennett has some fantasy value,
for sure.
8. Marty
Booker
(WR, signed by
Chicago from Miami)
- After being cut by the
rebuilding Dolphins due to his increasing age and declining
productivity, the 31-year-old Booker inked a reported two-year .5
million contract with his former team, the Bears. In 2007, Booker
posted a pathetic 50/556/1 as Miami’s possession guy. And he’s been
a weak producer for basically five years now. Since he had a
97-catch and a 100-catch season for Chicago several years ago, they
wanted him back to fill the void left by departed guys WR
Bernard Berrian and WR
Muhsin Muhammad. With only
WR
Devin Hester and WR
Mark Bradley in the mix for
Chicago, Booker should have a very prominent role in 2008. Yet, his
legs are far from young, and he can’t really stretch the field
anymore. Hence, the Bears get another guy who is “just a guy.”
Hansen’s Fantasy
Analysis: I
have to think the veteran Booker will start from Day One in his
second stint with the Bears. Despite the shaky quarterback
situation, that means Booker will be viable for fantasy,
particularly in a PPR league. The 32-year old (as of this July)
doesn’t have much verticality to his game these days (not that he
was ever a big downfield threat), but he remains a reliable
underneath possession receiver who excels running crossing routes
and catching passes in the red zone. If the Bears can get even
decent play at QB, he could catch 70+ passes, which would likely
make him a top-40 receiver, although one with little upside.
9. Keary
Colbert
(WR,
signed by Denver from Carolina)
- After four disappointing seasons with the
Panthers, Colbert got a fresh start via free agency when he signed a
three-year .2 million contract with the Broncos. Last year, Colbert
posted a pathetic bottom line of 32/332/0 in eight starts. Injuries
have limited the 26-year-old underachiever in the past, and
durability is a major issue with him, not to mention the fact that
he lacks focus and mental toughness. However, Denver plans to give
him every chance to compete against WR
Brandon Stokley for the #2
WR job next to up-and-coming star WR
Brandon Marshall now that
WR
Javon Walker has been
released. With just 109 career receptions and 7 career TDs, Colbert
came very cheap, which is probably why the very WR-needy Broncos
brought him into the fold.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: The interesting thing
about Colbert is we just don’t know what receiver the Broncos will
get. At his best, he’s a player who can be dangerous on the outside
or in the slot, and a player who runs good routes and catches most
everything thrown his way. The other Colbert is someone who
disappears for weeks at a time, gets hurt, drops key passes, and
someone who generally doesn’t have the size, speed, or explosiveness
to be an impact player. Colbert apparently turned a corner last year
in training camp, and he performed excellently. Yet, he basically
disappointed yet again during the regular season. The signing does
make some sense, however. He’s a veteran with a smidgen of upside,
and he’s versatile enough to play in the #2 role on the outside, or
he can play inside, if the team opts to let
Brandon Stokley stick as
the #2. Unfortunately for quarterback
Jay Cutler, there’s a
monumental drop-off from
Javon Walker to Colbert,
but at least Colbert has a pair of good knee.
10. Ernest
Wilford
(WR, signed by
Miami from Jacksonville)
- Wilford, a free-agent, left
Jacksonville after four years there and inked a four-year million
deal with Miami to be a starter with WR
Ted Ginn.
In 2007, the 29-year-old posted
45/518/3 in Jacksonville’s wideout committee. He has 14 career TDs.
Chances are that he’ll be utilized in Miami as a possession-type
weapon, since he’s lacking breakaway speed and chock-full of
toughness. At 6-4, he’ll definitely help the Dolphins’ red zone
offense as well since he can go up and snatch jump-balls and fades.
Now Miami just needs a stud to throw him the ball, as QB
John Beck and QB
Josh McCown are not guys to
get excited about.
Hansen's Fantasy
Analysis: I like Wilford as a
solid possession guy, and he was probably underused in Jacksonville
the last two years. He’s got good size and he’s pretty physical. But
the problem with him is obvious: He’s really slow. That was never
more evident to me than when I sat in at NFL Films and broke down
the tape of the Jag-Steeler playoff game. Wilford was shockingly
sluggish. Miami obviously sees something in him, but this is a very
underwhelming acquisition unless the team gets surprisingly good
play at quarterback, and until
Ted Ginn
emerges in 2008 as the deadly playmaker he should eventually become.
I’m not exactly expecting either to happen this year.
11. Drew Carter (WR, signed by Oakland from Carolina) - Carter, a 26-ye